Building Real Connection: How to Go Deeper Than Small Talk

December 9, 2025

👈 Back to: Dating 101: First Date Mastery | The Art of Texting Between Dates

This is Part 3 of the Dating 101: Beyond the Swipe series from The Average Dude. If you haven't read Parts 1 and 2, start there first.

You've Made It Past the First Few Dates. Now What?

So you've crushed the first date, nailed the texting game, and you're a few dates in. Things are going well. You're having fun, the chemistry is there, and you're both still interested.

But here's where a lot of people get stuck: you're still having the same surface-level conversations. "How was your day?" "What do you do for fun?" "Have you seen that new show?"

It's pleasant. It's safe. But it's not going anywhere deeper.

If you want to build something real—whether that's a serious relationship or just a genuine connection—you need to move beyond small talk and start having conversations that actually matter.

As The Average Dude, I'm here to show you how to build real connection without making it weird, forced, or uncomfortable. No therapy sessions on date three, just authentic conversations that help you actually get to know each other.

Why Surface-Level Dating Doesn't Work

Here's the problem with staying surface-level:

You never really know each other: You know their favorite food and what they do for work, but you don't know what makes them tick
The spark fades: Without depth, the initial attraction burns out quickly
You waste time: You could date for months and still not know if you're actually compatible
It feels empty: Fun dates are great, but without connection, it's just killing time
You can't build trust: Real relationships require vulnerability, and you can't be vulnerable at surface level

The goal isn't to rush into deep emotional territory on date two. It's to gradually move from "getting to know you" to "actually knowing you" in a way that feels natural and comfortable for both of you.

The Foundation: Creating a Safe Space for Real Conversation

Before you can go deep, you need to create an environment where both of you feel comfortable opening up.

1. Build Trust First

You can't expect someone to share their real thoughts, fears, and dreams if they don't trust you yet. Trust is built through:

Consistency: Following through on what you say you'll do
Reliability: Showing up when you say you will
Honesty: Being genuine about who you are and what you want
Respect: Honoring their boundaries and treating them well
Time: You can't force trust—it develops naturally over multiple interactions

Timeline: Usually takes 3-5 dates before people feel comfortable going deeper. Don't rush it.

2. Be Present and Engaged

Real connection requires your full attention:

Put your phone away: Not just face-down—actually away
Make eye contact: Shows you're engaged and interested
Listen actively: Not just waiting for your turn to talk
Ask follow-up questions: Dig deeper into what they're sharing
Remember details: Reference things they've told you before

People can tell when you're genuinely interested versus just going through the motions.

3. Share About Yourself Too

Connection is a two-way street. If you're only asking questions and never sharing, it feels like an interrogation, not a conversation.

The balance:

They share something → You respond with your own related experience
You ask a question → You answer it about yourself too
They open up → You match their level of vulnerability

This creates reciprocity and makes them feel comfortable sharing more.

How to Move Beyond Small Talk

The Conversation Ladder

Think of conversations as a ladder. You start at the bottom (surface level) and gradually climb higher (deeper connection). You can't skip rungs—you have to climb naturally.

Rung 1: Surface Level (Dates 1-2)

"What do you do for work?"
"Where are you from?"
"What do you like to do for fun?"
Safe, easy, getting-to-know-you basics

Rung 2: Interests and Opinions (Dates 2-3)

"What got you into that hobby?"
"What's your take on [current event]?"
"What kind of music/books/shows are you into and why?"
Starting to understand their preferences and perspectives

Rung 3: Values and Beliefs (Dates 3-5)

"What matters most to you in life?"
"What are you working toward right now?"
"How do you define success?"
Understanding what drives them and what they care about

Rung 4: Experiences and Stories (Dates 4-6)

"What's something you're really proud of?"
"What's been the biggest challenge you've overcome?"
"What's a moment that changed your perspective on life?"
Learning about their journey and what shaped them

Rung 5: Vulnerability and Depth (Dates 6+)

"What are you afraid of?"
"What do you want out of a relationship?"
"What's something you're working on improving about yourself?"
Real, honest, vulnerable conversations that build intimacy

Key point: You can't jump from Rung 1 to Rung 5. You have to climb naturally, and both people need to be on the same rung.

Questions That Actually Create Connection

Forget "What's your favorite color?" Here are questions that lead to real conversations:

About Their Passions

"What's something you could talk about for hours?"
"If money wasn't an issue, what would you spend your time doing?"
"What's a skill or hobby you've always wanted to learn?"
"What's the best part of your week?"

Why these work: People light up when talking about what they love. You see their authentic enthusiasm.

About Their Values

"What's something you believe that most people don't?"
"What's a cause or issue you really care about?"
"What qualities do you value most in the people around you?"
"What's a dealbreaker for you in relationships?"

Why these work: Reveals what matters to them and helps you assess compatibility.

About Their Experiences

"What's the best decision you've ever made?"
"What's something you've done that you're really proud of?"
"What's a lesson you learned the hard way?"
"What's been your favorite trip or adventure?"

Why these work: Stories reveal character and give you insight into who they really are.

About Their Future

"Where do you see yourself in five years?"
"What's something you're working toward right now?"
"What does your ideal life look like?"
"What's on your bucket list?"

Why these work: Shows their ambitions and helps you see if your futures could align.

About Their Perspective

"What's something that's changed your perspective recently?"
"What's the best advice you've ever received?"
"What do you think makes a relationship work?"
"What's something you used to believe but don't anymore?"

Why these work: Reveals how they think and how they've grown.

The Art of Vulnerability

Real connection requires vulnerability. But there's a right way and a wrong way to be vulnerable.

Good Vulnerability

What it looks like:

Sharing your genuine thoughts and feelings
Admitting when you don't know something
Talking about your goals and what you're working on
Sharing a meaningful story from your past
Being honest about what you're looking for

Example: "I've been working on being more present and less glued to my phone. It's harder than I thought, but I'm trying."

Why it works: It's honest, relatable, and shows self-awareness without being heavy.

Bad Vulnerability (Oversharing)

What it looks like:

Trauma-dumping about your ex or family issues
Sharing deep insecurities too early
Getting too emotional too fast
Making them your therapist
Sharing things that make them uncomfortable

Example: "My ex completely destroyed me and I don't know if I'll ever trust anyone again. Also, my relationship with my mom is really complicated..."

Why it doesn't work: It's too much, too soon, and puts emotional burden on someone you barely know.

The Vulnerability Balance

The rule: Match their level of vulnerability and gradually increase together.

They share something personal → You share something similar
You open up a little → See if they reciprocate
If they pull back → Don't push deeper
If they lean in → You can go a bit deeper

Vulnerability should feel like a natural exchange, not a one-sided confession.

Reading Compatibility: Are You Actually a Good Match?

Connection is great, but connection alone doesn't mean you're compatible. Here's what to look for:

Green Flags: Signs of Real Compatibility

Shared values: You agree on the big stuff (life goals, family, priorities)
Complementary communication styles: You understand each other and resolve conflicts well
Similar relationship goals: You both want the same things (casual, serious, marriage, kids, etc.)
Mutual respect: You admire and respect each other
Balanced effort: Both of you are equally invested
Natural chemistry: Conversation flows easily, you enjoy each other's company
Growth mindset: You both want to improve and support each other's growth
Aligned lifestyles: Your day-to-day lives could realistically fit together

Yellow Flags: Proceed with Awareness

Different communication styles: Can work if you're both willing to adapt
Different social needs: One introvert, one extrovert—requires compromise
Different life stages: Can work but needs honest conversation about timing
Different interests: Not a dealbreaker if you respect each other's hobbies
Past relationship baggage: Everyone has history—what matters is how they've processed it

Red Flags: Incompatibility Warning Signs

Misaligned core values: You fundamentally disagree on what matters most
Different relationship goals: One wants marriage, one wants casual—won't work
Unbalanced effort: You're doing all the work to maintain the connection
Poor communication: Constant misunderstandings or inability to resolve conflict
Disrespect: They dismiss your feelings, opinions, or boundaries
Incompatible lifestyles: Your day-to-day lives don't fit together at all
Unresolved baggage: They're clearly not over their ex or past trauma

Remember: Chemistry and compatibility are both important. Chemistry is the spark, compatibility is the fuel that keeps it burning.

Creating Meaningful Experiences Together

Deep conversations are important, but connection is also built through shared experiences.

Date Ideas That Foster Connection

Instead of dinner and a movie, try:

Cooking together: Collaborative, fun, and you're working as a team
Hiking or walking: Side-by-side conversations feel less intense than face-to-face
Trying something new together: Pottery class, escape room, rock climbing—shared novelty bonds people
Volunteering: See how they treat others and what they care about
Exploring a new neighborhood: Low-pressure, lots to talk about, easy to extend if it's going well
Game night: Reveals their competitive side, sense of humor, and how they handle losing
Museum or art gallery: Sparks interesting conversations about perspectives and preferences

Why these work better: They give you something to do together, not just sit and stare at each other. Shared activities create natural conversation and reveal character.

The Power of Novelty

Research shows that trying new things together increases bonding and attraction. Why?

Novel experiences trigger dopamine (the feel-good chemical)
Your brain associates that good feeling with the person you're with
You create unique memories together
You see different sides of each other

Pro tip: Mix familiar comfort (coffee dates, dinner) with novel experiences (new activities) to build both security and excitement.

The Timing: When to Go Deeper

There's no exact timeline, but here are general guidelines:

Dates 1-3: Foundation Building

Focus on getting to know each other's basics
Keep it light, fun, and positive
Build trust through consistency and respect
Assess initial chemistry and interest

Dates 4-6: Starting to Go Deeper

Move beyond surface-level topics
Share more about your values and what matters to you
Start having more meaningful conversations
Assess compatibility on important issues

Dates 7-10: Building Real Connection

Comfortable being more vulnerable
Discussing future goals and relationship expectations
Spending more quality time together
Deciding if this could be something serious

Beyond 10 Dates: Deepening the Relationship

Fully authentic with each other
Navigating challenges and conflicts together
Integrating into each other's lives (friends, family)
Making decisions about the future of the relationship

Important: These are guidelines, not rules. Some people connect faster, some slower. Follow the natural pace that feels right for both of you.

Common Mistakes That Kill Connection

Mistake #1: Rushing Intimacy

What it looks like: Trying to force deep conversations or emotional intimacy too early.

Why it backfires: Feels forced and uncomfortable. Real connection can't be rushed.

The fix: Let it develop naturally. Don't force it.

Mistake #2: Staying Too Surface-Level

What it looks like: Never moving past small talk, even after multiple dates.

Why it backfires: The relationship stalls and fizzles out from lack of depth.

The fix: Gradually introduce deeper questions and topics. Take small steps toward vulnerability.

Mistake #3: Making It All About You

What it looks like: Dominating conversations, not asking about them, always steering back to your stories.

Why it backfires: They feel unheard and unimportant.

The fix: Remember the 70/30 rule from our first date guide. Let them talk more than you do.

Mistake #4: Avoiding Difficult Topics

What it looks like: Never discussing important things like relationship goals, dealbreakers, or what you're looking for.

Why it backfires: You waste time with someone who wants completely different things.

The fix: Have the important conversations before you're too invested. It's okay to ask what they're looking for.

Mistake #5: Ignoring Red Flags

What it looks like: Overlooking incompatibilities because you like them or the chemistry is good.

Why it backfires: Those red flags become bigger problems later.

The fix: Pay attention to what they show you. Believe their actions, not just their words.

Having "The Talk": What Are We Doing Here?

At some point, you need to have the conversation about where this is going. Here's how to do it without making it weird:

When to Have It

After 6-10 dates (or 1-2 months of dating)
When you're both clearly invested and spending regular time together
Before you're too emotionally attached to walk away if you want different things
When you need clarity to move forward

How to Bring It Up

Good approaches:

"I'm really enjoying getting to know you. I'm curious—what are you looking for right now?"
"I like where this is going. I wanted to check in and see if we're on the same page about what we're doing here."
"I've been thinking about us. I'd like to know what you're looking for in terms of dating."

Bad approaches:

"So are we boyfriend/girlfriend or what?" (too aggressive)
"Where is this going?" (too vague and puts pressure on them)
Bringing it up via text (have this conversation in person)

What to Discuss

What you're both looking for (casual, serious, open to seeing where it goes)
Whether you're seeing other people or want to be exclusive
What your expectations are moving forward
Any dealbreakers or important compatibility factors

Remember: This conversation should feel natural, not like a business negotiation. You're just making sure you're on the same page.

🔗 Ready to make it official? Check out Part 4: When to Make It Official for the complete guide on having the DTR (Define The Relationship) conversation.

The Average Dude's Connection-Building Principles

Be genuinely curious: Actually want to know who they are, not just what they look like
Share authentically: Be yourself, not who you think they want you to be
Listen actively: Hear what they're saying and what they're not saying
Respect the pace: Don't rush connection—let it develop naturally
Create experiences: Do things together, not just talk about doing things
Be vulnerable appropriately: Open up gradually and reciprocally
Pay attention to compatibility: Chemistry is great, but values and goals matter more long-term
Communicate clearly: Don't play games or leave them guessing

Final Thoughts

Building real connection takes time, effort, and vulnerability from both people. You can't force it, fake it, or rush it.

The right person will make it feel natural. Conversations will flow, vulnerability will feel safe, and you'll both be equally invested in getting to know each other.

If you're doing all the work, if they're not opening up, or if it feels forced—that's your answer. Real connection should feel like a relief, not a struggle.

So take your time. Ask real questions. Share authentically. Pay attention to compatibility, not just chemistry. And don't settle for surface-level when you deserve something deeper.

The goal isn't just to date someone. It's to find someone you actually connect with—someone who gets you, challenges you, and makes you want to be better.

That's worth waiting for.

- The Average Dude

Quick Connection-Building Checklist

Building Trust:

☐ Be consistent and reliable
☐ Follow through on what you say
☐ Respect their boundaries
☐ Be honest about who you are

Going Deeper:

☐ Move beyond small talk gradually
☐ Ask meaningful questions about values and experiences
☐ Share about yourself too—make it reciprocal
☐ Match their level of vulnerability

Assessing Compatibility:

☐ Discuss relationship goals and expectations
☐ Pay attention to shared values
☐ Notice how you communicate and resolve differences
☐ Don't ignore red flags

Creating Experiences:

☐ Try new activities together
☐ Create shared memories
☐ Mix comfort with novelty
☐ See how they handle different situations

📚 DATING 101: BEYOND THE SWIPE SERIES

Part 1: First Date Mastery
Part 2: The Art of Texting Between Dates
Part 3: Building Real Connection (You are here)
Part 4: When to Make It Official →

🎥 Watch on TikTok @TheAverageDude | 🎧 Listen on Spotify